The Dangerous Assumptions Driving ICE Arrests

Credit: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Public Domain, via Flickr


The budget of the Department of Homeland Security has risen from $10 billion in 2024 to $85 billion in 2025, becoming the highest-funded federal law enforcement agency in the US. The extra funds have been allocated to surveillance and hiring more U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents. However, little has gone toward providing adequate training, with recruits becoming ICE agents after only 56 days. With the administration’s focus on the southern U.S.-Mexico border, a rise in discrimination against Central and South American or Latino immigrants, migrants, and U.S. citizens has been alarming. This increase is observable by both the disproportionate detention rates and stories of harassment and unlawful arrests of Latino residents.  

ICE Creating “Criminals”

During Trump’s second administration, mass deportation campaigns have interchangeably used words like “criminals” or “illegals” when referring to immigrants. This creates the inaccurate stereotype that “immigrants are criminals”. Conservative political and media networks are actively working to racialize these stereotypes. They aim to link “being a criminal” with “being an immigrant” or “being Latino.”


The Politics of Who Belongs

ICE has no authority over US citizens, so there is concern that these biases are being used to rationalize ICE’s increased policing and detaining rates. They have been exacerbated by the U.S. Supreme Court’s fast-tracked decision last September to effectively re-permit racial profiling. According to the decision, ICE agents can now legally consider a person to be a suspicious target based on identity markers like race and speaking Spanish.

These tactics are discriminatorily impacting Latino residents. Javier Ramirez, a U.S. citizen of Mexican descent, was arrested by ICE and taken to a detention center for 5 days. During his arrest, he explained he was a U.S. citizen and even dialed 911, while ICE officers refused to listen to him and claimed he was lying. As ICE raids become more rampant in U.S. cities, so do risks for unlawful arrests of those with valid citizenship identification, like Ramirez. 

Graph shows which actions taken by immigration officers are viewed as acceptable and unacceptable

Credit: How Americans See Immigration Officers’ Behaviors and Civilian Actions, Pew Research Center, Washington, D.C. (January 29, 2026)


Minority Populations are the Majority of Those Detained

The New York Immigration Coalition has kept track of ICE’s racial profiling and disproportionate arrest rates. In 2025, Ecuadorians living in New York made up 24% of ICE arrests, despite only 4% of the non-citizen population being Ecuadorian. Similarly, 8% of ICE arrests were Guatemalan, although they make up 1% of the non-citizen residents. The same statistics hold on a national scale. Across all states, the ICE arrest rates of Mexicans, Hondurans, Venezuelans, and Peruvians are disproportionately higher than the actual population.

U.S. Customs and Border Protection agent detains large group of illegal immigrants at U.S. Mexico border in Yuma, AZ

Credit: U.S. Customs and Border Protection, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

These campaigns of “kicking out criminals” are failing to resonate across the nation. A 2026 poll from Pew Research reveals 72% of Americans think it is unacceptable for ICE agents to use a person’s spoken language or looks as justification for arrest. Additionally, 54% believe it’s also unacceptable to increase ICE presence in neighborhoods with immigrants. 

Americans, citizens and non-citizens, are increasingly working to protect their neighbors by spreading information about how to exercise their rights and resist unlawful arrest by ICE. Some are even setting up community alert systems, using car horns or whistles to warn residents about ICE presence. Migration has always been a part of human civilization. Immigrants make up our communities, schools, families, and friends. When united, we can better protect our neighbors and loved ones from this unlawful harassment. We must work to build solidarity within communities to find the power for change.

Protesters against US Immigration and Customs Enforcement hold signs displaying support for immigration

Credit: Trevor Stone, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

This article was written by a guest contributor, S. Jarvis.


Learning Cycle Logo

Learn from real business case samples and empower your organization with DEI strategies. Visit our About Us page to explore further.

Top Posts This Week


Learning Cycle Editorial Team

We explore DE&I topics worldwide, aiming to foster global diversity, particularly in workplaces. With contributors from various countries, we share insights to educate and solve common issues, striving to create a better world!!

Join us every Tuesday and Thursday for fresh insights, inspiring stories, and practical advice on advancing diversity, equity, and inclusion. Plus, don’t miss our exclusive monthly DEI events and seminars page!


Categories